Let the Dough Tell the Story

Experience pizza redefined. At Cheltenham Pizza House, every detail is deliberate. From our signature dough, aged to perfection over 72 hours, to carefully selected premium ingredients layered with care. Each pizza is meticulously hand stretched and stone baked to achieve a delicate balance of crispness and softness that is both rustic and refined.

Pizza made with patience, intention, and love for the craft.

Where Every Pizza Tells a Story

We celebrate the art of pizza with an experience that blends tradition, technique and flavor. Our Traditional Pizzas honor timeless favorites, from the freshness of simple ingredients to the richness of layered cheeses and vibrant flavors.

Our Gourmet Pizzas bring bold and distinctive creations, showcasing the finest seasonal ingredients, earthy notes, decadent pairings and spice infused flavors.

From classic pizzas to contemporary creations, our menu offers a journey for every palate.

72 hr Pizza Dough

Hand Streched

Stone Baked

Craft. Crust. Community.

Step into the essence of Cheltenham Pizza House where every image reflects the artistry and passion behind our craft. From the warmth of stone baked pizzas emerging from the oven to the joy of gatherings around the table, our gallery captures moments that make each visit unforgettable.

Experience It Now

Order now or visit Cheltenham Pizza House for a slice of pure indulgence. Whether it is a quick bite or a leisurely dinner, every pizza is served fresh from the oven, hot and full of flavor, crafted to satisfy every craving.

What Our Guests Are Saying

The finest praise comes from those who have savored our creations. From exquisite flavors to the effortless warmth of our service, our guests’ words capture the essence of an unforgettable experience. Explore their reflections and discover why so many return for moments worth relishing.

Cheltenham Pizza House is an absolute gem! They craft some of the most delicious, high-quality pizzas I’ve ever had, using fresh, locally sourced ingredients. The location on Railway Road is perfect, offering a cozy atmosphere for casual dining or quick takeout. Their menu has something for everyone, whether you’re into classic flavors or love trying unique combinations. The warm and welcoming vibe, along with their dedication to quality, truly sets them apart. Whether you’re dining in or taking it to-go, it’s always a great experience. Highly recommend for all pizza lovers in the area!

We had Pizza for dinner tonite. We thoroughly enjoyed it .My mother and Father is Italians and they enjoyed every mouthful and we where totally impressed the restaurant is so clean and the staff very friendly. We will be back and refer family and friends thanks again

Great little pizza restaurant. Beautiful, authentic and yummy pizzas with fresh ingredients. Staff are really nice and it's kid-friendly which is a huge bonus. Our new local for sure!

Great food had the pasta and pizza. Pizza crust was divine 😋 highly recommend. The chef came out to ask if everything was good. Love a place that takes pride in food quality and service. Best pizza I've had in years

Overall experience was amazing. Taste was really nice and the price for the pizza is very much unbelievable in this inflation (large pizza for less than $20). Really enjoyed visiting this place. Staffs were very kind and good service.

That is hands down the best pizza I had recently! We ordered twice in the past week ! Excellent ! It's like a mix of suburban pizza and woodfire pizza with that light dough. It always hits the spot ✨

This place would have to be Cheltenham’s hidden gem. The pizzas are generous in size, the toppings are well balanced and the pizza base is perfect and crispy. It would have to be the best valued and quality pizza restaurant in Bayside. Definitely worth a visit you won’t be disappointed.

Always a refreshing vibe with the classical Italian music and polite staff. We ordered a Greek pizza, Neapolitan pizza and garlic bread, all of which were delicious, as well as affordable.

These guys are absolutely amazing. Their food is excellent and the service is top notch. The venue is so quaint and beautiful. I’ve come back here a couple of times already and the food is exactly the same as before. Every single time. Absolutely amazing. Keep up the great work guys.

We love this little pizza place. Really amazing pizzas with fresh ingredients, and unlike a lot of pizza shops, they're even open for lunch! Highly recommend

Honestly such amazing food and service! The pizza especially was divine and I would absolutely recommend. I love the atmosphere with lovely music and the sweetest service!

Just found this place online , was looking for a place to have lunch with my son and he said let’s eat pizza. I’m not a big pizza fan however I’ll say this is the best pizza I have had in a very long time Good service , quality product , good value for money Must try , we had the pepperoni

We tried this pizza house for the first time tonight and it was absolutely amazing! Friendly service, great atmosphere (music was fantastic and the place was a vibe) as my daughter said! And the best pizzas! The caprese salad was delish 😋 Keen to try more pizza and some dessert!

One of the best pizza places I have been to. The portions here are so generous, loved their Parma and cheesy pizza.🍕 The Service here was a 10/10. Must try.

Cheltenham Pizza place - I would rate 5/5, excellent customer service, great ambience and the place is so clean and very well maintained. Pizza’s are freshly made with thin crust and generous toppings and amazingly delicious food. I still can’t forget the taste of the authentic pizzas and the variety of juices and smoothies that we ordered. I would strongly recommend this place for those who want to try delicious food and peaceful place to hangout with friends and family. Thank you to the business owner and the staff for an exceptional service when we dined in.

Best pizza we have had in such a long time. Flavours were great and the base was cooked to perfection. Staff were so friendly too.

Reserve Your Table, Savor the Experience

Planning a cozy dinner, a family gathering, or a special night out? Book your table at Cheltenham Pizza House and indulge in an evening where culinary excellence and luxury meet. Secure your place and allow us to create a dining experience beyond expectation.